Head-to-head comparison
Blue Guardian vs TradeDay: Which Futures Prop Firm Wins? (2026)
A side-by-side breakdown of the rules that decide which prop firm fits your strategy — drawdown type, profit splits, payout speed, account sizes, and total cost.
Blue Guardian
- From
- $55
- Account sizes
- $25K – $150K
- Profit split
- 100%
- Payout
- —
TradeDay
- From
- $88
- Account sizes
- $50K – $150K
- Profit split
- 80%
- Payout
- —
The verdict
Blue Guardian has the lower starting price ($55.25 vs $87.5 for TradeDay). Blue Guardian offers a higher max profit split (100% vs 80%). Blue Guardian offers a one-time payment option, avoiding recurring monthly fees. Blue Guardian has an instant-funding path with no evaluation phase.
Rules side by side
Each value is the best (or full range) across all of the firm's products.
| Rule | Blue Guardian | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Challenge type | Evaluation + Instant Funding | Evaluation |
| Drawdown type | EOD | Intraday Trailing / EOD / Static |
| Account sizes | $25K – $150K | $50K – $150K |
| Starting price | $55 | $88 |
| Profit split | 100% | 80% |
| Payout speed | — | — |
| Payout frequency | — | — |
| Consistency rule | Eval: 0–40% | Eval: 30–30% |
| Payment model | One-time | Subscription |
| Verified payouts | No | No |
| Sage rating | — | 4.2 / 5 |
About each firm
Blue Guardian
Blue Guardian's futures arm offers four challenge tiers including Standard (EOD drawdown), Pro (one-day pass, no daily loss limit), Rapid (soft-breach daily loss limits), and Instant funding. Payouts are processed in 48 hours, with a 100% split on the first $15,000 and 90% thereafter. Supported platforms include Tradovate, ProjectX, Volsys, and Deepcharts.
Products
- Standard — One-time · 100% split
- Rapid — One-time · 100% split
- Instant — Instant funding · One-time · 100% split
- Pro — One-time · 100% split
TradeDay
TradeDay offers a 2-step futures evaluation with day-one payouts, no activation fees, and education + mentoring included.
Highlights
- Day-one payouts after passing evaluation
- No activation fee
- Up to 6 concurrent funded accounts
- Education and mentoring included
Products
- Intraday — 80% split
- End of Day — 80% split
- Static — 80% split
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper to start, Blue Guardian or TradeDay?
Blue Guardian has the lower starting price at $55 for its smallest evaluation account, compared to $88 for the other.
Which has the better profit split, Blue Guardian or TradeDay?
Blue Guardian pays out a higher max profit split (100%) compared to 80% on the other side.
Are payouts verified at Blue Guardian and TradeDay?
Blue Guardian does not have third-party verified payout history. TradeDay does not have third-party verified payout history.